Why Consider Dual Filing Strategy

German professionals pursuing US green cards often face difficult choices. Should you file EB-2 NIW with its more accessible qualification standards? Or aim higher with EB-1A for potentially faster processing? The answer might be both.

Filing Both EB-2 NIW and EB-1A as a Professional in Germany represents a strategic approach maximizing your approval chances. Instead of choosing one pathway and hoping for the best, you pursue two simultaneously. This dual filing strategy makes sense when you have a strong EB-2 NIW case but uncertain EB-1A qualification. Your achievements might meet extraordinary ability standards, but you're not completely confident.

Filing both hedges your uncertainty. If EB-1A gets denied, your EB-2 NIW application continues independently. If both approve, you choose which to use based on processing timelines. Many accomplished German professionals find their credentials fall into that gray zone between clear EB-2 NIW qualification and possible EB-1A approval.Beyond Border frequently recommends dual filing for accomplished German professionals whose credentials fall into that gray zone between clear EB-2 NIW qualification and possible EB-1A approval.

‍

‍

Understanding EB-2 NIW Requirements

The EB-2 National Interest Waiver requires an advanced degree or bachelor's plus five years of progressive experience. Most German professionals with master's degrees easily meet this educational threshold. The critical requirement is proving national importance. Your work must serve substantial US interests. Technology professionals developing AI solutions, engineers advancing renewable energy, researchers improving healthcare outcomes, and similar contributions demonstrate national importance.

You must satisfy three Dhanasar prongs. First, your proposed work has substantial merit and national importance. Second, you're well positioned to advance this work. Third, waiving normal requirements benefits America. EB-2 NIW cases succeed with solid professional achievements like publications in respected journals, patents on useful technologies, leadership roles in important projects, and recognition from industry peers.

You don't need extraordinary ability or sustained international acclaim. Strong professional credentials suffice. Processing takes eight to eighteen months from filing to green card. Premium processing reduces I-140 review to 45 days for an additional $2,805 fee. Government filing fees total $700 for the I-140 petition, with additional costs for adjustment of status or consular processing later in the process.

Understanding EB-1A Requirements

The EB-1A extraordinary ability category sets much higher qualification bars. You must demonstrate sustained national or international acclaim in your field. You need either a major internationally recognized award or meet three of ten criteria established by USCIS regulations.

These criteria include nationally recognized prizes, membership in associations requiring outstanding achievements, published material about you in major media, judging others' work, original contributions of major significance, scholarly articles, exhibitions of your work, leading roles in distinguished organizations, high salary, or commercial success. For German professionals, this translates to significant achievements like founding successful companies, leading critical projects at major organizations, publishing highly cited research, speaking at premier conferences, or receiving industry awards.

The bar sits considerably higher than EB-2 NIW. Many accomplished professionals have strong EB-2 NIW cases but fall short of EB-1A extraordinary ability standards. Processing timelines mirror EB-2 NIW at eight to sixteen months. Premium processing is available for the same $2,805 fee, reducing I-140 adjudication to 45 days. The government filing fee remains $700 for the I-140 petition, identical to EB-2 NIW.

The Logic Behind Dual Filing

Qualification uncertainty drives dual filing decisions. You might have borderline EB-1A credentials where your achievements are impressive but not definitively extraordinary. Filing only EB-1A risks denial if immigration officers conclude you haven't demonstrated sustained acclaim. Starting over with EB-2 NIW after denial wastes months of processing time.

Filing only EB-2 NIW might succeed but leaves potential EB-1A advantages unexplored. EB-1A typically has shorter wait times for visa numbers in certain situations. Filing both simultaneously eliminates this dilemma entirely. Your EB-2 NIW application provides a safety net while your EB-1A attempt reaches for the higher category.

If EB-1A approves, excellent. If it gets denied, your EB-2 NIW continues unaffected. Either way, you secure permanent residency through one pathway or the other. The strategy also preserves priority dates effectively. Whichever I-140 approves first establishes your priority date. If you later upgrade categories or face any changes, that early priority date transfers with you, protecting your place in line.

Is Dual Filing Legally Permitted

USCIS explicitly allows filing multiple I-140 petitions simultaneously. No regulations prohibit this strategy whatsoever. Each I-140 petition is evaluated independently based on its own merits. Approval or denial of one doesn't impact the other in any way. They're completely separate applications processed by different adjudicators.

Many immigration attorneys recommend dual filing for borderline cases. It's a standard strategy used regularly, not some creative loophole or risky approach. The only consideration is ensuring each petition stands alone with sufficient evidence. Don't just copy one petition to create the other. Each needs tailored arguments and documentation specific to that category's requirements.

Your EB-2 NIW petition emphasizes national interest contributions and how your work benefits America. Your EB-1A petition focuses on extraordinary ability evidence and sustained acclaim in your field. These different emphases require different expert letters, evidence organization, and legal arguments throughout the petitions. The approach and tone differ significantly between the two applications.

Cost Considerations for Dual Filing

Dual filing obviously costs more than single applications since you're preparing and filing two complete I-140 petitions. Each I-140 requires a $700 filing fee, meaning two petitions cost $1,400 in government fees. Premium processing adds $2,805 per petition if desired, totaling $5,610 for both applications with expedited processing.

Attorney fees represent the larger expense in most cases. Preparing one strong I-140 petition typically costs $8,000 to $15,000 depending on complexity. Dual filing might cost $16,000 to $35,000 total depending on case complexity and attorney rates. Some attorneys offer discounted rates for dual filing since evidence overlaps significantly between petitions. The second petition requires less work than preparing two completely independent cases from scratch.

For German professionals, total costs including government fees, premium processing, and attorney services typically range $18,000 to $40,000 for both petitions combined. This investment buys significant insurance against denial. You dramatically increase approval probability and reduce risk of complete denial, making the investment worthwhile for many professionals whose credentials fall in the borderline zone.

Beyond Border provides transparent cost estimates during consultations, helping German professionals understand total investment required for dual filing strategies and making informed decisions.

Strategic Advantages of Dual Filing

Risk mitigation represents the primary advantage of dual filing. You're not putting all eggs in one basket. If one petition faces issues, requests for evidence, or ultimately denial, the other continues processing independently without negative impact. Priority date preservation matters significantly for long-term immigration planning. Whichever I-140 approves first establishes your priority date, which determines when you can file for adjustment of status or process your immigrant visa.

Earlier priority dates provide advantages, especially if visa backlogs develop in your category over time. Having the earliest possible priority date protects you against future delays. Flexibility in case selection offers another benefit worth considering. If both petitions approve, you can choose which to pursue based on processing timelines, current circumstances, or strategic considerations at that moment.

Appeal options expand with dual filing as well. If EB-1A gets denied, you can appeal that decision while your EB-2 NIW continues processing independently. The appeal doesn't slow down or affect your other petition. Some German professionals file EB-2 NIW first, then add EB-1A later after gaining more achievements. This sequential approach also works, though simultaneous filing maximizes efficiency by getting both applications in the queue immediately.

Documentation Requirements for Both Petitions

Both petitions need core evidence of your qualifications. Academic credentials showing degrees from German universities need credential evaluations confirming US equivalency. Employment letters detailing responsibilities, achievements, and impact must be comprehensive. Publications demonstrating expertise in your field should be included with citation data. Patents proving innovation need complete documentation with explanation of their significance.

EB-2 NIW specifically requires national interest documentation. Government reports showing your field's importance to America help establish the first Dhanasar prong. Policy statements emphasizing priorities in your area strengthen arguments. Expert letters from recognized figures explaining your work's national significance must be detailed and specific to national interests rather than general praise.

EB-1A specifically requires extraordinary ability evidence. Major awards and recognition need documentation proving their significance and competitiveness. Media coverage in prominent outlets must be substantial, not just brief mentions. Speaking invitations at premier events demonstrate your standing in the field. Evidence of your high compensation compared to others in your field helps prove extraordinary ability. Letters from distinguished individuals attesting to your acclaim must come from truly recognized experts.

The evidence overlaps significantly but requires different framing and emphasis. Your research publication might demonstrate expertise for EB-2 NIW while proving original contributions of major significance for EB-1A. The same evidence serves both purposes but needs different contextual explanations. Expert letters need tailoring to each petition with different focus areas. EB-2 NIW letters emphasize national importance and benefit to America. EB-1A letters emphasize your extraordinary standing and recognition in the field.

Preparing both petitions simultaneously allows efficient evidence gathering. You collect comprehensive documentation once, then organize it appropriately for each application with different narrative frameworks and legal arguments.

Timeline Considerations

Both petitions can be filed simultaneously or sequentially depending on your situation. Simultaneous filing maximizes efficiency and establishes priority dates immediately for both categories. Sequential filing might make sense if you're gathering additional achievements for EB-1A. You could file EB-2 NIW immediately to secure an early priority date, then add EB-1A months later after publishing more research or receiving awards.

Processing times run similarly for both categories. Form I-140 takes six to twelve months for regular processing or 45 days with premium processing. Both petitions process independently without affecting each other. One might approve while the other faces requests for evidence. One might approve quickly while the other takes longer. They don't influence each other's outcomes.

After I-140 approval, you proceed with adjustment of status if already in the US or consular processing in Germany if applying from abroad. This stage is identical regardless of which category is approved. The final green card process doesn't differ based on whether you used EB-2 NIW or EB-1A for your I-140 approval.

Common Concerns About Dual Filing

Some professionals worry dual filing signals uncertainty about qualifications. This concern is unfounded. USCIS evaluates each petition independently based on evidence presented without considering other pending applications. Others fear rejection of one petition might prejudice the other. This doesn't happen in practice. Each adjudicator evaluates their assigned case without reference to other pending petitions for the same beneficiary.

Cost concerns are valid. Dual filing costs significantly more than single applications. However, for borderline cases where EB-1A qualification is uncertain, the increased approval probability often justifies the investment. Some professionals worry about looking indecisive or uncertain about their qualifications. Remember that immigration officers see dual filing regularly. It's a recognized strategy demonstrating thoroughness and seriousness about immigration rather than indecision.

The only real downside is financial cost. If you're absolutely certain you qualify for EB-1A or clearly only meet EB-2 NIW standards, dual filing wastes money. But for those in the gray area, it's insurance worth purchasing.

FAQ

Can I legally file both EB-2 NIW and EB-1A simultaneously? 

Yes, filing both EB-2 NIW and EB-1A as a professional in Germany is completely legal and explicitly permitted by USCIS regulations, with each I-140 petition evaluated independently without conflicts.

What are the main advantages of dual filing?

 Dual filing maximizes approval probability by hedging qualification uncertainty, preserves the earliest priority date regardless of which approves first, and provides appeal options if one petition faces denial while the other continues.

How much does it cost to file both petitions? 

Total costs for dual filing typically range $18,000 to $40,000 including two $700 I-140 filing fees, potential premium processing at $2,805 each, and attorney fees of $16,000 to $35,000 for preparing both comprehensive petitions.

Do both applications process at the same speed? 

Both EB-2 NIW and EB-1A I-140 petitions take six to twelve months for regular processing or 45 days with premium processing, though individual cases may vary, with each petition processed completely independently.

What happens if both petitions get approved? 

If both petitions approve, you can choose which category to use for final green card processing based on current processing times, visa availability, or strategic preferences, with both approvals remaining valid.

‍