Why Choose EB-2 NIW Over Other Green Card Paths?

The EB-2 National Interest Waiver (NIW) is for professionals whose work benefits the U.S. Unlike other employment-based green cards, it does not require a job offer or employer sponsorship.

For O-1 holders, EB-2 NIW offers an alternative path to EB-1A. EB-1A focuses on your past achievements and extraordinary ability, while NIW emphasizes your proposed future work and its expected national impact.

Self-Petition Freedom

The NIW allows you to petition independently without employer involvement. You don't need:

• An employer to sponsor you
• A job offer from a U.S. company
• Labour certification (PERM process)
• Employer cooperation or support

This independence suits entrepreneurs, cross-institutional researchers, consultants, and anyone with a dynamic career-you control the process.

Future-Focused Evaluation

EB-1A focuses on your achievements. NIW focuses on your future work in the U.S.

USCIS looks at your proposed endeavour-the work you'll pursue in the United States. You demonstrate how this work benefits U.S. national interests. This forward-looking approach suits people building companies, conducting research, or creating solutions to national challenges.

Your past achievements support your ability to execute future work. NIW shifts focus from "What have you done?" to "What will you do, and why does it matter for the U.S.?"

Lower Bar Than EB-1A

EB-1A requires being among the highest achievers in your field with international recognition over time. EB-2 NIW requires an advanced degree (or equivalent) and contributions of national importance.

NIW is available to professionals who do not meet the EB-1A eligibility requirements. You can be an expert in your field without international acclaim.

NIW Criteria: The Dhanasar Three-Prong Test

EB-2 NIW approval requires meeting the Dhanasar test, named after the 2016 case Matter of Dhanasar. This test replaced the older NYS DOT framework and has three requirements. You must satisfy all three.

Prong 1 - Substantial Merit and National Importance

Your proposed work must have substantial merit and national importance.

Substantial merit means your work has significant value or impact. It need not generate immediate economic results, but should address vital problems or advance critical fields.

National importance means the impact goes beyond a single employer, region, or industry. The benefit must reach the wider U.S. population, the U.S. economy, or U.S. interests.

USCIS accepts many types of nationally important work:

• Technology advancing critical industries (AI, cybersecurity, clean energy)
• Research addressing public health challenges
• Business ventures spur job creation and economic growth.
• Work supporting education, infrastructure, or national security
• Innovations improving U.S. competitiveness globally

You don't need to show your work benefits in all 50 states. Local or regional work can be nationally important if it addresses issues relevant to the U.S. as a whole.

Examples of nationally important work:

• AI researcher improving healthcare diagnostics nationwide.
• Startup founder creating jobs in the emerging technology sector
• Engineer developing renewable energy solutions
• Scientist researching disease prevention methods
• Tech professional advancing U.S. competitiveness in critical industries.

Prong 2 - Well-Positioned to Advance the Endeavour

You must be clearly well-positioned to achieve your proposed work.

USCIS evaluates:

• Education: Advanced degrees, specialised training, certifications
• Experience: Track record in your field, relevant work history
• Skills: Technical abilities, expertise, qualifications
• Plan: Detailed, achievable roadmap for your proposed endeavour
• Progress: Evidence you've already started or made headway
• Resources: Funding, partnerships, institutional support

Your O-1 accomplishments are strong evidence of your capabilities and success, demonstrating that you can deliver on your plan.

The Proposed Endeavour Statement (PES) is critical for this prong. This detailed document explains:

• What you will do
• How will you do it
• Timeline and milestones
• Resources available to you
• Why you're the right person for this work

Strong evidence for Prong 2:

• Advanced degrees (Master's, PhD) in relevant fields
• Publications, patents, or innovations you've created
• Work experience demonstrating relevant expertise
• Recommendation letters from experts validating your qualifications
• Funding you've secured (grants, investment, contracts)
• Partnerships or collaborations supporting your work
• Early results or proof of concept

‍

‍

Prong 3 - Beneficial to Waive Job Offer Requirement

You must demonstrate that waiving the standard job offer requirement benefits the United States.

Normally, employment-based green cards require:

1. A U.S. employer sponsors you.
2. The employer proves that no qualified U.S. workers are available (PERM labour certification)
3. The employer offers you a permanent job.

NIW waives these requirements. For Prong 3, you explain why this waiver serves U.S. national interests.

USCIS considers:

• Impracticality: Is getting a job offer impractical for your work? (Common for entrepreneurs, self-employed consultants, and researchers working across institutions)
• Independence: Does your work require flexibility or independence? (Startup founders, researchers pursuing novel ideas, consultants)
• Urgency: Is your work time-sensitive or too important to delay with PERM? (Public health research, critical technology development)
• Unique position: Are you uniquely suited to advance this endeavour? (Specialised expertise, unique background, singular qualifications)

Most O-1 holders cite entrepreneurship (running your own company), research independence (working at multiple institutions), or strategic importance (critical work that cannot wait).

When NIW Makes Sense

Not all O-1 holders are suited to EB-2 NIW. Knowing when NIW fits ensures you select the optimal green card route.

Ideal Candidates for EB-2 NIW

When to Choose NIW Over EB-1A

Choose EB-2 NIW when:

• The EB-1A bar is too high for your current profile.
• Your work has a clear national benefit, but not "very top of the field" acclaim.
• You need flexibility across employers or self-employment.
• Your work is entrepreneurial and requires building something new.

Dual Filing Strategy

Many O-1 holders file EB-2 NIW while maintaining O-1 status. This strategy:

• Maintains work authorisation through O-1
• Locks in priority date early (critical for India/China-born applicants)
• Creates risk mitigation
• Makes sense given priority date backlogs

For India-born applicants with 13+ years of backlogs, filing an NIW immediately preserves the earliest possible priority date.

EB-2 NIW Processing Time and Timeline

Understanding timelines helps you plan your green card journey from an O-1 visa.

I-140 Processing

Standard processing: 8-12 months Premium processing (45 days): Available as of 2025

Priority Date Wait Times

• Rest of World: 1-2 years
• India: 13+ years
• China: 2-3 years

Total timeline from filing to green card:

• Rest of World: 2-3 years (1.5-2 years with premium)
• India: 14-17+ years
• China: 3-5 years

Concurrent Filing Benefits

When your priority date is current, you can file Form I-485, Application to Adjust Status. This allows you to apply for:

• Employment Authorisation Document (EAD): 5-8 months
• Advance Parole (travel authorisation)
• Derivative benefits for spouse and children under 21

Unlike O-3 dependents, who are not authorised to work, your family members are authorised to work with an EAD.

Reusing Your O-1 Evidence for EB-2 NIW

One advantage O-1 holders have is the evidence they already have. Much can be reused, though it must be reframed.

Evidence That Carries Over

• Awards and recognition: Proves you're well-positioned (Prong 2)
• Publications and citations: Establishes expertise and impact (Prongs 1 & 2)
• Press coverage: Validates national importance (Prong 1)
• Judging roles: Shows recognised expertise (Prong 2)
• Leadership positions: Indicates capability and resources (Prong 2)
• High remuneration: Suggests market recognition (Prong 2)

How to Reframe Your Evidence

O-1 focuses on past achievements. NIW focuses on future impact.

Instead of "I received this award, proving extraordinary ability," write "I received this award, demonstrating the expertise needed to execute my proposed work advancing U.S. interests in renewable energy."

Instead of "I've published 15 papers," write "My 15 publications establish expertise in AI diagnostics, positioning me to develop the healthcare technology described in my proposed endeavour."

The same achievements support your case when connected to your future work and its national importance.

‍

‍

Common Mistakes to Avoid

Understanding common mistakes helps you avoid them.

Vague Proposed Endeavour Statement

"I will continue my research" doesn't work. USCIS needs specific, achievable plans with clear milestones, resources, and connections to national importance.

Overemphasising Past Achievements

O-1 holders often submit NIW petitions that are heavy on past achievements and light on future plans. Balance is critical. Use past achievements to prove capability (Prong 2) while emphasising the importance of future work (Prong 1).

Weak National Importance Argument

"My company will be successful" isn't of national importance.

"My company will create 50 jobs in the next three years, advance U.S. competitiveness in renewable energy, and contribute to reducing carbon emissions by developing technology that makes solar power 20% more efficient" is of national importance.

Connect your work to broader U.S. interests, including economic growth, critical industries, public health, infrastructure, global competitiveness, and national security.

Missing Advanced Degree Requirement

Before the NIW arguments even matter, you must qualify for EB-2 in one of two ways:

1. Advanced Degree: A U.S. master’s (or higher) or a foreign equivalent; or a bachelor’s plus 5 years of progressive post-bachelor experience.
2. Exceptional Ability: Evidence that you meet the exceptional ability standard (shown by satisfying multiple regulatory criteria).

If you don’t clearly fit one of these EB-2 bases, the NIW case usually fails even if your proposed endeavour is strong.

Maximise Your EB-2 NIW Success with Expert Guidance

Transitioning from O-1 to EB-2 NIW requires a different approach than EB-1A. The Proposed Endeavour Statement, Dhanasar's arguments, and national importance framing need expertise.

Beyond Border specialises in helping O-1 holders build strong NIW cases, particularly for entrepreneurs and technology professionals.

Schedule your free consultation and profile evaluation→

Frequently Asked Questions

Can O-1 visa holders apply for EB-2 NIW?

Yes. O-1 holders can apply for EB-2 NIW while maintaining O-1 status. The O-1 is a dual-intent visa, meaning you can pursue permanent residency without affecting your temporary status.

Is EB-2 NIW easier than EB-1A for O-1 holders?

Generally yes. EB-2 NIW has a lower bar than EB-1A. You don't need to prove you're at the "very top" of your field with sustained international acclaim. Instead, you need an advanced degree and work of national importance. 

However, NIW requires a detailed proposed endeavor and stronger national importance arguments than EB-1A.

Do I need a job offer for EB-2 NIW?

No. The National Interest Waiver specifically waives the job offer and labor certification requirements. You can petition independently without employer sponsorship or a permanent job offer.

What's the Dhanasar test?

The Dhanasar test has three requirements you must satisfy: 

(1) your proposed endeavor has substantial merit and national importance, 

(2) you're well-positioned to advance the endeavor, and 

(3) on balance, it benefits the United States to waive the job offer requirement. All three prongs are mandatory.

Can I use my O-1 evidence for EB-2 NIW?

Partially. Your O-1 evidence helps demonstrate you're well-positioned to advance your proposed work (Prong 2). However, you need additional evidence for national importance (Prong 1) and a detailed Proposed Endeavor Statement explaining your future work. The evidence must be reframed for NIW's forward-looking evaluation.

How long does EB-2 NIW take from O-1?

I-140 processing takes 8-12 months standard (or 45 days with premium processing). If your priority date is current and you file I-485 concurrently, the total time to a green card is 7-16 months. 

If you're from India or China, expect 2-13+ years of waiting for your priority date to become current before you can file Form I-485.

What if I'm from India or China?

You'll face the same priority date backlog as other EB-2 applicants. India currently has a backlog of 13+ years, and China has a backlog of 2-3 years. File your I-140 as early as possible to preserve your priority date. Many applicants from backlogged countries file both EB-1A and EB-2 NIW simultaneously to maximize chances and preserve the earliest possible priority date.

Is EB-2 NIW good for entrepreneurs?

Yes. EB-2 NIW is one of the best green card paths for entrepreneurs because it doesn't require a job offer and allows complete self-employment. You demonstrate how your company creates jobs, advances important industries, or benefits U.S. economic interests. 

Can my family members obtain green cards through an EB-2 NIW?

Yes. Your spouse and unmarried children under 21 automatically receive derivative green cards when you're approved. Unlike O-3 visa holders, who cannot work, your family members receive full green cards with immediate authorization to work. After five years, your entire family becomes eligible for U.S. citizenship.

Should I file an EB-2 NIW or an EB-1A from an O-1?

It depends on your profile.

Choose EB-1A if you have sustained international acclaim, major awards, extensive prestigious media coverage, and meet the extraordinary ability standard. 

Choose EB-2 NIW if you have an advanced degree, nationally important work, and a clear proposed endeavor but don't meet EB-1A's highest bar. Many O-1 holders file both applications simultaneously to maximize their chances of success.