Understanding the Second Dhanasar Prong

The Matter of Dhanasar decision requires National Interest Waiver applicants to satisfy three prongs. The second prong demands that you are well-positioned to advance your proposed endeavor. This goes beyond merely having good ideas or impressive credentials. You must prove you can actually execute.

Well Positioned to Advance the Endeavor Evidence for Germany-Based NIW Applicants requires demonstrating that you possess the specific combination of education, skills, knowledge, track record, and resources necessary to successfully pursue your proposed work in the United States. Immigration officers evaluate whether you're likely to actually deliver on the contributions you propose.

This prong recognizes that national importance alone doesn't justify waiving requirements if you lack capability to advance the work. Conversely, being highly qualified doesn't matter if your work doesn't serve national interests. All three prongs must be satisfied for approval.

German professionals sometimes assume their strong academic credentials automatically satisfy positioning requirements. While education matters, officers want comprehensive evidence of capability including practical experience, demonstrated achievements, and concrete plans for executing your work in America.

The positioning evaluation is forward-looking but grounded in past performance. Officers assess your historical track record as the best predictor of future success. They examine your resources and plans to determine feasibility. They consider whether you have realistic paths to achieving what you propose.

Think of positioning as answering: "Why should we believe you'll successfully accomplish what you propose?" Your evidence must provide compelling answers grounded in concrete facts about your qualifications, achievements, and circumstances.

Beyond Border helps German professionals develop comprehensive positioning evidence documenting not just impressive credentials but practical capability to execute proposed endeavors through systematic presentation of education, experience, achievements, and resources.

‍

‍

Educational Credentials and Professional Training

Educational qualifications form the foundation of positioning evidence, though they alone don't satisfy the second Dhanasar prong without additional elements demonstrating capability.

Advanced degrees from German universities provide strong educational credentials. Master's degrees, diplomas, and doctorates from institutions like TU Munich, RWTH Aachen, TU Berlin, Karlsruhe Institute of Technology, or University of Heidelberg demonstrate rigorous technical training. Include official transcripts showing coursework, grades, and degrees conferred.

Credential evaluations are essential for German degrees. Immigration officers may not understand German educational systems or degree nomenclature. Obtain evaluations from approved agencies like Educational Credential Evaluators (ECE), World Education Services (WES), or Josef Silny & Associates confirming your German credentials equal specific U.S. degree levels.

Specialized training beyond degrees strengthens positioning. Professional certifications, specialized courses, technical training programs, or continuing education in your field demonstrate ongoing skill development. Include certificates, transcripts, or completion documentation for relevant training.

Doctoral research provides particularly strong positioning evidence since dissertations demonstrate ability to conduct independent research, develop novel approaches, and contribute original knowledge to fields. Describe your dissertation topic, methodological approaches, and findings showing research capability.

Thesis and dissertation advisors can provide powerful validation. Letters from doctoral advisors or master's thesis supervisors explaining your research capabilities, intellectual contributions, and potential for future achievements carry significant weight given their deep knowledge of your work.

Academic honors and distinctions during education prove excellence. Summa cum laude, magna cum laude, departmental honors, competitive scholarships, or academic awards all demonstrate you excelled relative to peers. Include documentation of any educational honors received.

German professionals should present educational credentials comprehensively with proper documentation, evaluations, and contextualization helping immigration officers understand the rigor and relevance of their academic preparation.

Work Experience and Progressive Responsibility

Professional experience demonstrates practical capability beyond academic training. Immigration officers want to see you've successfully applied your knowledge in real-world contexts.

Progressive work experience shows increasing expertise and responsibility over time. Document your career progression from early roles through current positions, highlighting how responsibilities expanded, technical complexity increased, and your scope of influence grew. This trajectory proves developing capability rather than stagnation.

Detailed employment letters from supervisors provide crucial evidence. Letters should describe specific responsibilities, projects you led or contributed to significantly, technical challenges you solved, innovations you developed, and impact of your work. Generic letters confirming employment dates help minimally compared to detailed descriptions of your contributions.

Leadership roles demonstrate positioning to advance work requiring coordination or team management. If you've led research teams, managed technical projects, supervised junior professionals, or held positions of responsibility, document these roles showing capability to drive initiatives forward.

Technical depth in specialized areas proves domain expertise. Work experience should demonstrate you've developed deep knowledge in specific technical areas relevant to your proposed endeavor. Broad generalist experience matters less than specialized expertise in fields central to your NIW case.

Cross-functional experience can strengthen positioning by showing you understand multiple aspects of bringing innovations to fruition. Experience spanning research, development, commercialization, or implementation demonstrates comprehensive capability beyond narrow technical focus.

International experience working across countries or cultures can prove adaptability. Having worked successfully in German and American contexts, or having collaborated internationally, shows you can navigate different professional environments effectively.

Current employment in the United States provides particularly strong positioning evidence when you're already performing work related to your proposed endeavor. You're not theoretically positioned but actively engaged in the work you propose to continue.

German professionals should present work experience not merely as a chronological listing but as a compelling narrative of developing expertise, accumulating capabilities, and demonstrating increasing ability to advance complex technical or professional challenges.

Resources, Facilities, and Support Systems

Being well-positioned requires not just personal qualifications but also access to resources necessary for advancing your proposed endeavor. Officers evaluate whether you have realistic means to execute your plans.

Current employment providing necessary resources strengthens positioning significantly. If you're working for companies or institutions with facilities, equipment, data, or resources essential to your work, describe this access. Explain how your employer's resources enable your proposed endeavor even though you're self-petitioning.

Letters of support from institutions or organizations demonstrate concrete backing. If universities, research institutions, companies, or other entities have expressed interest in supporting your work, include letters confirming this support. These letters show you're not working in isolation but have institutional backing.

Funding sources or financial support prove resources exist for your work. If you have research funding, employment providing salary, investment for business ventures, or other financial resources, document these. Financial capability matters for work requiring resources beyond just your personal efforts.

Collaborative relationships provide access to expertise and resources beyond what you alone possess. If you have established collaborations with other researchers, partnerships with organizations, or access to networks enabling your work, document these relationships. Letters from collaborators confirming ongoing partnerships strengthen positioning.

Technical infrastructure access matters for work requiring specialized equipment, computing resources, laboratory facilities, or other technical infrastructure. Describe access to necessary infrastructure through employment, institutional affiliations, or other arrangements.

Data access is critical for data-intensive work. If your proposed endeavor requires specific datasets, explain how you have or will obtain access to necessary data through employment, institutional arrangements, or public sources.

Location advantages can support positioning. If you're in geographic areas with concentrations of relevant companies, research institutions, or industry clusters, explain how this location facilitates your work through proximity to collaborators, customers, or resources.

German professionals should think comprehensively about resources enabling their work and document access to necessary support systems beyond just personal qualifications.

Beyond Border helps German applicants identify and document all relevant resources, collaborations, and support systems demonstrating practical capability to execute proposed endeavors rather than just theoretical qualifications.

FAQ

What education do I need to be well-positioned for EB-2 NIW?

 Well positioned to advance the endeavor, evidence for Germany-based NIW applicants includes advanced degrees like master's or doctorate from recognized German universities with credential evaluations, though education alone doesn't suffice without work experience and track record of achievements.

How important is work experience versus education? 

Both matter significantly, with education providing foundational qualifications while work experience and track record of achievements demonstrate practical capability to execute, with immigration officers weighing demonstrated accomplishments over credentials alone.

What if I have limited publications?

 Industry professionals can compensate with patents, products developed, employer recognition, salary levels showing market value, or other achievement evidence appropriate to non-academic contexts, with expert letters explaining field norms regarding publications.

Do I need to be in the U.S. to be well-positioned? 

No, German-based applicants can demonstrate positioning through German employment, international collaborations, plans for accessing U.S. resources, and transferability of expertise, though current U.S. employment provides particularly strong evidence when present.

What role do expert letters play in proving positioning?

 Expert letters provide crucial third-party validation of your qualifications by explaining why your specific combination of education, experience, achievements, and resources makes you particularly capable of advancing nationally important work in your field.

‍