Understanding i-140 Withdrawal Rights and Procedures

i-140 withdrawal authority rests exclusively with the petitioning employer who filed the immigrant petition, not with the beneficiary employee for whom the petition seeks permanent residency. This fundamental principle stems from the legal framework treating employers as petitioners asserting business need for foreign worker services, giving them control over petition lifecycle including withdrawal decisions. Employers maintain withdrawal rights regardless of petition approval status, meaning they can withdraw pending petitions before adjudication or revoke approved petitions after USCIS grants them.

The withdrawal process requires petitioning employers to submit written requests to USCIS specifically identifying the petition by receipt number, filing date, and beneficiary information. Withdrawal requests should include detailed explanations of reasons for withdrawal such as employment termination, business closure, financial difficulties, or changed circumstances eliminating the position or need for the beneficiary. USCIS processes withdrawal requests administratively, updating case status to withdrawn and sending confirmation notices to both petitioner and beneficiary. Can i-140 be withdrawn is a common question with the straightforward answer that yes, employers possess unilateral withdrawal authority at any time, though important limitations protect beneficiaries after certain thresholds are met.

‍

‍

Employer Motivations for i-140 Withdrawal

Employers pursue i-140 withdrawal for various legitimate business and employment relationship reasons. Employment termination represents the most common withdrawal trigger, with employers withdrawing petitions when beneficiaries resign, are terminated for cause, or when mutual separations occur ending the employment relationship. Since i-140 petitions affirm permanent job offers and employer intent to employ beneficiaries in specific positions, employment relationship termination logically leads to withdrawal as the underlying premise no longer exists.

Company financial difficulties, business closures, or organizational restructuring sometimes force i-140 withdrawals when employers can no longer support positions or afford prevailing wage salary commitments required by approved petitions. Mergers, acquisitions, or corporate reorganizations create situations where successor entities decline to assume predecessor's i-140 obligations, leading to withdrawal requests. Some employers strategically withdraw i-140 petitions as leverage during employment disputes or to prevent former employees from using approved priority dates with new employers, though legal protections limit this tactic's effectiveness after 180-day approval thresholds.

Fraud discoveries or material misrepresentations uncovered after approval sometimes prompt employer-initiated withdrawals to correct records and avoid potential liability for knowingly maintaining fraudulent petitions. In rare cases, USCIS requests employers withdraw petitions to facilitate administrative corrections or avoid formal revocation procedures when issues arise post-approval. Understanding employer withdrawal motivations helps beneficiaries anticipate potential risks and take protective actions like monitoring petition status, maintaining positive employment relationships, and pursuing alternative immigration pathways when employer reliability seems questionable. Beyond Border advises beneficiaries on strategies to protect immigration interests when employer withdrawal risks emerge, including priority date preservation tactics and alternative petition development.

The Critical 180-Day Threshold and Beneficiary Protections

The 180-day approval period creates crucial protections limiting i-140 withdrawal consequences for beneficiaries even when employers exercise withdrawal rights. Immigration law provisions enacted through AC21 and subsequent regulations establish that approved i-140 petitions remaining valid for at least 180 days create permanent priority date rights for beneficiaries regardless of subsequent employer withdrawal. This means if your i-140 was approved and remained approved for 180 continuous days before employer withdrawal, your priority date from that petition stays valid for use with future i-140 petitions filed by different employers.

The 180-day threshold also protects beneficiaries with pending I-485 adjustment of status applications, allowing job portability to new employers in same or similar occupations after 180 days from I-485 filing, even if original sponsoring employers withdraw underlying i-140 petitions. This AC21 portability provision prevents employers from using withdrawal threats to trap foreign workers in unfavorable employment situations once adjustment applications reach the 180-day milestone. USCIS cannot automatically revoke approved i-140 petitions solely due to employer withdrawal after 180 days when beneficiaries have pending or approved I-485 applications based on those petitions.

Timing calculations for the 180-day period begin from the i-140 approval date, not filing date, making approval timing critical for beneficiary protections. Employers who withdraw approved petitions before reaching 180 days can eliminate priority date rights and potentially derail pending adjustment applications if withdrawals occur before beneficiaries reach I-485 180-day portability thresholds. Strategic monitoring of approval dates and 180-day anniversary timing helps beneficiaries understand when critical protections vest, reducing vulnerability to employer withdrawal actions that could otherwise devastate immigration timelines.

Beneficiary Options When Facing i-140 Withdrawal

Beneficiaries cannot directly prevent or reverse i-140 withdrawal actions since petition ownership rests with employers, but several strategic options exist to protect immigration interests when withdrawal threats emerge. First, beneficiaries should attempt negotiating with employers to delay withdrawal until after critical 180-day thresholds pass, potentially offering considerations like extended notice periods, transition assistance, or non-compete waivers in exchange for maintaining petitions long enough to secure priority date rights and portability protections.

If employment relationships deteriorate beyond repair, beneficiaries should immediately pursue alternative i-140 petitions with new employers to establish backup priority dates and redundant pathways toward permanent residency. Self-petition options through EB-1A extraordinary ability or EB-2 National Interest Waiver pathways provide employer-independent alternatives immune to employer withdrawal since beneficiaries control these petitions directly. Developing strong self-petition cases before employment relationship problems escalate provides insurance against employer withdrawal actions.

Beneficiaries with pending I-485 applications approaching or exceeding 180 days should expeditiously secure alternative employment with employers willing to file new i-140 petitions supporting AC21 portability, allowing adjustment applications to continue despite original employer withdrawals. Documentation proving new positions meet same or similar occupation requirements becomes critical for successful portability claims. Legal consultation immediately upon learning of potential withdrawal helps beneficiaries understand specific options, timeline constraints, and protective actions available in their particular circumstances. Beyond Border provides emergency consultation services for beneficiaries facing imminent i-140 withdrawal threats, developing rapid response strategies to preserve priority dates, protect pending adjustment applications, and establish alternative immigration pathways minimizing disruption to permanent residency timelines.

USCIS Processing of Withdrawal Requests

i-140 withdrawal processing by USCIS follows administrative procedures prioritizing petitioner control while implementing statutory beneficiary protections. When employers submit withdrawal requests, USCIS verifies the request comes from authorized petitioner representatives, confirms petition identification details match agency records, and updates case status to withdrawn. The agency sends Form I-797 withdrawal notices to both petitioning employers and beneficiaries documenting the withdrawal action and effective date.

For approved petitions withdrawn within 180 days of approval, USCIS revokes approval completely and invalidates associated priority dates, treating petitions as if never approved. Beneficiaries lose priority date rights and any pending I-485 applications based solely on withdrawn i-140 petitions typically face denial unless alternative approved petitions support continued processing. However, when approved petitions existed for over 180 days before withdrawal, USCIS maintains priority date validity for beneficiaries despite employer withdrawal, documenting this in withdrawal notices and preserving dates for future petition use.

USCIS processing times for withdrawal requests vary from immediate administrative actions to several weeks depending on case complexity and whether additional investigation into circumstances becomes necessary. Some withdrawal requests trigger fraud investigations if timing or circumstances suggest improper motivations, potentially delaying final processing while USCIS examines underlying petition validity. Beneficiaries should monitor case status online and through attorney representation to track withdrawal processing and understand when actions become effective, allowing timely responses to protect immigration interests.

Strategic Considerations Around Withdrawal Timing

Understanding i-140 withdrawal timing implications helps both employers and beneficiaries make informed decisions about when and whether to pursue withdrawal actions. Employers contemplating withdrawal should consider timing relative to 180-day approval thresholds, recognizing that withdrawals after this period provide less leverage over beneficiaries due to priority date retention and portability protections. Some employers strategically delay withdrawals until resolving separation agreements or obtaining beneficiary cooperation on transition matters.

Beneficiaries should proactively monitor i-140 approval anniversaries, calendar 180-day thresholds from both i-140 approval and I-485 filing dates, and understand protection vesting timelines. When employment relationships show strain, beneficiaries benefit from accelerating alternative petition development, pursuing self-petition options, or negotiating transition timelines that preserve critical protections before employer withdrawal actions eliminate them.

Priority date retention importance varies based on country of birth and category, with Indian and Chinese beneficiaries valuing early priority dates far more than rest of world applicants due to severe retrogression in those countries. Strategic withdrawal timing considerations differ substantially between scenarios involving beneficiaries from backlogged versus current countries, affecting negotiation leverage and protective action urgency. Beyond Border provides strategic timing guidance helping clients navigate withdrawal scenarios through comprehensive analysis of applicable protections, optimal response timing, and alternative pathway development that protects long-term permanent residency goals regardless of employer withdrawal actions.

FAQ

Can employers withdraw i-140 petitions after approval?

Yes, employers can pursue i-140 withdrawal at any time including after USCIS approval, though withdrawals after petitions have been approved for 180 days do not eliminate beneficiary priority date rights or affect pending I-485 applications under AC21 portability.

Can beneficiaries withdraw their own i-140 petitions?

No, beneficiaries cannot directly withdraw i-140 petitions since petition ownership belongs to sponsoring employers as petitioning party, though beneficiaries can request employers withdraw on their behalf without legal obligation for employers to comply with such requests.

What happens to my priority date if the employer withdraws i-140?

If your i-140 was approved for at least 180 days before employer withdrawal, your priority date remains valid for future petitions with new employers regardless of withdrawal, protecting your place in the visa number allocation line for permanent residency.

Can i i40 be withdrawn if I-485 is pending?

Can i i40 be withdrawn even with pending I-485 applications, though if your adjustment application has been pending over 180 days, AC21 portability allows continuing adjustment with new employer sponsorship despite the original employer's i-140 withdrawal.

How do employers officially withdraw i-140 petitions?

Employers submit written withdrawal requests to USCIS identifying petitions by receipt number and beneficiary information, explaining withdrawal reasons, and receiving confirmation notices documenting withdrawn status and effective dates for both petitioner and beneficiary records.